Skip to main content
Posted August 17, 2026

Accounting Coordinator

First Insurance Group
Bloomington, IN, US Full Time

Job Description

Job Description

Job Description

Accounting Coordinator

Position Title: Accounting Coordinator

Department: Accounting / Finance

Reports To: Controller

FLSA Status: Non-Exempt (or Exempt, as determined by company policy)

Position Summary

The Accounting Coordinator is responsible for supporting the daily accounting operations of the agency by maintaining accurate financial records, reconciling insurance commissions, processing company payables, and assisting with month-end accounting activities. This position works closely with the Controller, agency owners, insurance carriers, and employees to ensure timely and accurate financial reporting and excellent internal customer service.



Benefits

Paid Time Off (PTO)

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Life Insurance

Hands on Training

Mon-Fri Schedule

Retirement Plan

Disability Insurance


Responsibilities

Essential Duties and Responsibilities

Accounting & Financial Operations

Perform direct bill commission reconciliations for all Property & Casualty policies.

Review daily bank activity and reconcile transactions with AMS360 accounting records.

Process and reconcile insurance company payables.

Record bi-weekly payroll journal entries.

Assist with end-of-month accounting procedures and financial reconciliations.

Assist with direct bill commission reconciliation for Life & Health policies as needed.

Financial Controls

Verify the accuracy and completeness of financial transactions.

Investigate and resolve accounting discrepancies.

Maintain organized accounting records and supporting documentation.

Ensure accounting procedures comply with agency policies and carrier requirements.

Communication & Customer Service

Communicate professionally with agency owners, producers, insurance carriers, and employees.

Respond promptly to accounting inquiries.

Collaborate with all departments to resolve accounting issues.

Administrative Support

Assist the Controller with additional accounting and administrative duties.

Participate in special projects and process improvement initiatives.

Maintain confidentiality of financial and employee information.

Disclaimer

This job description is intended to describe the general nature and level of work performed. It is not intended to be an exhaustive list of all duties, responsibilities, or qualifications. Responsibilities may be modified as business needs change.



Requirements

Qualifications

Associate degree in Accounting, Finance, Business, or related field preferred, or equivalent experience.

Accounting or insurance agency accounting experience preferred.

Strong attention to detail and organizational skills.

Excellent communication and analytical abilities.

Technical Skills

AMS360 or similar agency management system experience preferred.

Microsoft Excel, Word, and Outlook proficiency.

Accounting software and online banking experience preferred.

Core Competencies

Accuracy and attention to detail

Integrity and confidentiality

Organization and time management

Initiative and dependability

Customer service orientation

Teamwork and collaboration

Physical Requirements

Ability to sit for extended periods.

Ability to lift up to 10 pounds occasionally.

Ability to use standard office equipment.

Working Conditions

Office environment with standard business hours and occasional overtime during month-end and year-end closing periods.

Sign up for Job Alerts